
Do you dream of publishing your book with a traditional publisher?
You’ve written your story and used Fictionary StoryTeller to make sure the structure is strong. You have a reader grabbing plot, superstar characters, and a deeply impactful setting. You’ve incorporated feedback from Beta readers, critique partners, and possibly a structural editor and copy editor in order to revise your book into a polished masterpiece.
With the writing the best it can be, you’re ready for publishing, right? Well, yes and no. Most publishing houses won’t take submissions without an agent.
What Are Literary Agents?
A literary agent’s job is to sift through the slush piles. They find authors who create manuscripts that are polished enough to prove the author knows what they are doing and the work fits the market.
They are experts in knowing what the publishing houses are looking for and following the book market trends. They keep up to date on what is currently out and what other agents are pitching.
Agents are your all around cheerleaders and business managers. They may request edits on your part, negotiate book contracts with publishing houses, protect your artistic rights, make sure you are being paid fairly, and deal with the publishing house representatives.
They also negotiate foreign, film, or tv rights. And they may negotiate with any voice actors you hire for your audiobooks. So, when your book empire expands, your literary agent is on the front lines, smoothing the way.
Literary agents work with both new authors and established ones. Even authors like Nora Roberts, Stephen King, and John Grisham have literary agents.
Do You Need a Literary Agent?
If you plan to traditionally publish with a publishing house, then you’ll likely need an agent. Most publishing houses only work through agents now and don’t accept unsolicited submissions.
How to Get a Literary Agent in 8 Steps
Read
“Read in your genre” is common writing advice. It helps you understand what genre expectations readers have, what modern conventions of story are being used, current pacing and themes. But consider what reading can do for your literary agent search.
When you find favorite authors or books that inspire you, consider taking a look at the agent that took a chance on it and sold that book to the publishing house. The agent is often thanked in the acknowledgements section or mentioned on the author’s website, though you may have to stoop to an online search.
These agents have the potential to be a good match for you. They are reputable, have at least one good sale in their repertoire, and they have similar taste to you. The agent already has the skills to pitch and sell work similar to yours. And all this investigative work will pay off in later steps.
Browse Literary Agency Directories and Find Good Matches
You may already have some names from the previous step, but here you are going to check to make sure those agents are open to submissions in your genre. You can also browse the directories, using your genre keywords to find more agent names.
Here is a list of directories, some online, some in printed form, and some available in both:
- Query tracker, both free and paid version. Many agents only take queries through Query Tracker. Query Tracker also sends out a monthly newsletter listing agents who are on the lookout for manuscripts.
- Reedsy has their own agent list. Not sure how often it is updated, so finding a seeking agent might be hit or miss.
- Publisher’s Marketplace has both paid and unpaid services.
- DuoTrope is a paid only service. This isn’t just a directory, on their site they say that their “publication and agent listings are up to date and full of information you won’t find elsewhere. We also offer submission trackers, custom searches, deadline calendars, statistical reports, and extensive interviews”
- Writer’s Market is a yearly printed book that you could purchase or find at your local library.
- Writer’s Digest not only posts names of agents that are seeking submissions, but they have articles on writing and interviews too.
- Manuscript Wishlist (MSWL) has more detailed information about what the agent is looking for.
- Agent Query is a free database.
- Association of Authors’ Representatives, Inc. (AAR) – online, or in print
- The Writer’s and Artist’s Yearbook can be purchased or found at your local library.
- Poets and Writers has their own directory. You just need to sign up for a free account.
Know Your Book’s Competition
Writing to genre beats is different from placing your book on bookshelves (both literal and metaphorical ones). Look at what is going on in the market, ask author friends, beta readers, librarians, etc. for comp ideas and vet them.
Consider who your target audience is. This will affect what kind of agent you look for and what your publishing dreams may be.
It is important that your book is in a finished state if you are querying fiction. The agent or publisher will likely send you edits, but they expect it to be in an already polished state before they accept a manuscript.
Find at least three competitors (comps) within the last few years that are not bestsellers to adequately describe what your book is like. A comp is a title similar to your book in some way. You want something that has sold to a wide audience and consistently.
The reason you avoid bestsellers is because agents don’t want to hear that your book is the next Harry Potter or Twilight, because the way those stories took off was unexpected. Consider instead what matches your story best plot wise or structurally.
Comps are also places to look for agents. In the acknowledgement or bio section of the book, the author often mentions their agent. And if the book is similar to yours or you love the writing and think it is similar to yours, the agent might be interested in your work.
Once you can compare what your story is like, then focus on what makes your story unique. How is it different from what is already out there? Brandon Sanderson pitched his book as “what happens if the dark lord wins at the end of the epic quest?” Think: Sauron gets the ring at the end of The Lord of the Rings.
Research and Vet Agents
Read what agents are looking for. Usually I start with the basic list and look for agents, who open to submissions, that work in my genre. Then I go to their biography and read more specifically what they are looking for, what their favorite books are, and what kind of hobbies they have.
This gives me a basic idea of whether I would get along with them and if they are a good fit for the story I wrote.
Things like their client list might give you an idea if they represent works like yours, but you don’t want it to be too similar because then they won’t take on an author that will steal resources from a current client.
What you are trying to do is find someone who is as passionate as you are about getting your book published. I’ve seen interviews with agents/editors that passed over books/authors that later became very famous and the response is profound.
If they had picked up the book, it probably wouldn’t have done as well as it ended up doing because they wouldn’t have fought as hard for it.
An unspoken rule is to only query one agent in an agency. If your manuscript is promising, but that agent doesn’t have the space or inclination for it, they will pass it to any other agent in their agency that they think would like it.
So a rejection from an agent is a rejection from an agency. However, that only applies to that manuscript. You may still send other manuscripts to that agency.
You might also want to do an online search for the agent and see if you can find any more information about them or interviews they have done. This will give you more information for a future step.
Query in Small Batches
Sometimes when you query, you’ll get feedback from agents. Querying in small batches of 5-15 agents, allows you to make necessary changes to either your manuscript or your query copy between submissions.
This will also allow you the time to update your query copy as time goes on. Perhaps something important in your bio changes, or you think your manuscript might be more marketable in a different genre, or after revisions your word count has changed, etc. Just like your resume should be updated often, so should your query copy.
Write Personalized Query Letters
Since you already did your research about the agent before querying them, you have the information to personalize the first paragraph of your query letter. If you are not sure what a query letter is or how to write one, check out this blog by Shane Millar, Query Letter Examples | Fictionary.
Basically, a one page query letter introduces your story to agents. This should include a greeting, introduction, hook, mini-synopsis, author bio, comp titles, and a closing.
The first paragraph should be a personalized greeting to the agent of your choice.
Be careful to spell their name correctly and use the most up to date information you have about them. Check their agency site, their LinkedIn page, and any social media they may be on. The more you can tailor this paragraph to the agent, the more likely they are to keep reading.
If you have been to a pitch session, or met them at a convention, this is a great place to mention that.
Double check the submission requirements from the agent or agency. Some want shorter or longer query letters, some only accept queries through query tracker, or a direct work email, some want the first three pages of your manuscript and some want the first twenty (No one wants the full manuscript unless asked). Also look at any formatting expectations.
The synopsis is generally five hundred words, present tense, and covers all of the main plot points and character development in your book, including the ending. This reassures the agent that you know how to write a full story.
I keep a folder for querying copy within each manuscript folder where I have a pitch/logline, my blurb, a query letter, a synopsis, and documents that are the most common denomination of first chapters/pages of my manuscript.
This simplifies the querying process and I only need to do simple changes to personalize my submission. I am also sure that these documents have been properly edited and proofread, so no silly mistakes slip by. This shows the agent my professionalism and attention to detail.
Deal with Requests, Rejections, and Radio Silence
I create a spreadsheet (even though they aren’t my favorite things) to keep track of agents, agencies, when I sent the query, when a rejection was made, when a request was made, any notes, and what status the query is in. Because three things are going to happen within the following days, weeks, or months.
Most likely you’ll receive nothing. Most agents are so overwhelmed with their slush piles that they don’t have time to respond to every rejection or they may be taking a long time to read through the queries. After waiting about six months with no response, consider the query to be closed.
If you are someone who needs closure, a quick follow-up email that is neutral (‘Have you had a chance to look at my query?’ OR ‘If you need more time with my manuscript please let me know.’)
Keep it professional and don’t let your frustration or imposter syndrome show.
If the agent provides an expected time response window in their submission guidelines, be respectful and don’t contact them before that time is up. Maybe even pad it with an extra week or two.
The second most likely thing to happen is a rejection (sorry, but them’s the breaks). Usually it is a standard, “We’re sorry but your manuscript isn’t the best fit for my list,” sort of thing. However, you may get feedback which you may or may not want to incorporate. And you might also get a “resubmit when you make these changes,” which is great! But still technically a rejection—just with hope
I got a request! Okay, keep it together…Follow the guidelines for submitting your full manuscript and add a nice note of thanks to the agent. The request may be followed up by a rejection or—offer.
Now I know you will really be losing it at this point, but don’t jump in too quickly. If you have a list of dream agents who you haven’t submitted to yet, now would be a good time to send them an email stating that you’ve had an offer and are giving them a chance to take a look.
Pick the Right Agent
Before accepting an agent, ask to meet with them in person or on the phone. This will give you an idea of how you will get along. Consider it like a blind date and ask a list of questions.
Things like, what is the best way to communicate? How long should I expect a response? What is your favorite/least favorite thing about my writing? What is your publishing plan? How long do you want to sign a contract for?
Take your time to investigate what the agent’s proposal for your manuscript is. Have a few discussions to see if your personalities and plans for the future align. Choosing an agent doesn’t have to be a lifelong commitment but it will last for as long as the contract you sign.
Again, consider choosing an agent that is the most enthusiastic about your book and any future ideas you have. They are the one who will fight to get things done for you. Choosing an agent is like choosing a champion who will represent you when publishing gets tricky.
And just like vanity presses, beware of fake agents that ask for money from you. Check Writer Beware to see if your “agent” is on the list. A true agent works off commissions. They will only get a percentage of your book’s earnings. The current market rate is fifteen percent.
Check to make sure they are a member of the Association of American Literary Agents (AALA) and their name is known in literary circles. Verify that they work for the agency they claim to.
Check their sales track record. See if they treat you as an equal partner, contacting you in a timely manner, and communicating respectfully and professionally with you. And make sure you are treating them the same way.
New agents will have fewer contacts, but more time for you. More established agents will know the ins and outs of publishing, but you may be low on their list of priorities. After all, they are working for free until the book sells.
A good literary agent will be honest with you about publisher rejections and work out a game plan with you if the book needs work or should be repositioned in the market. They should help you improve your manuscript, if necessary, and put together your query copy.
The agent is expected to understand the fine details of book contracts and how to navigate around finding the best deal for you and your book. They are there for you to find you opportunities, celebrate your successes, and dry your tears during the rough times.
Tips For Finding a Literary Agent
Use Fictionary
As I mentioned before, it is important to have the best story you can before querying. Not only should the manuscript be completed, but it should also be polished as much as you can, so that you put your best foot forward.
Because once you query an agent and are denied, that agency is off the table, at least for a year or so as you overhaul your query materials including your manuscript sample. Then you could probably query a different agent at the agency.
Fictionary StoryTeller software can help you create a structurally sound story. With elements that focus on characters, plot, and setting, you’ll know that your manuscript is well balanced and fleshed out.
Taking some of the free classes and Fictionary Live Courses will help you build your story knowledge and improve the manuscript you have to share with agents.
Ask Questions
Even after you’ve signed on the dotted line, continue to ask questions. The relationship between you and your agent should be a partnership. If there is anything you don’t know or are unsure about, your agent should fill you in.
Dream Agent
Don’t think that your dream agent is off the table because they are too busy managing the “greats.” The reality is that authors are human beings too. They may die, retire, decide to write something completely different, etc. In those cases an agent will have openings. They will want someone new to bring fresh work and perspective to things.
So, don’t give up. It is possible that the literary agent of your heart might be open to submissions. Just keep your proverbial eyes and ears open.
Listen to Your Gut
Even if everything seems on the up and up, even if your interactions with your agent have gone smoothly, listen to your instincts. Often our brains “see” and interpret information unconsciously and you may not be able to explain why but you feel the relationship isn’t right.
You have the right to be picky and choose the right agent for you without settling just so you can say you have an agent.
No Agent is Better Than a Bad One
Any job should be enjoyable. Yes, it will be hard work and frustrating at times, but anything you can do to facilitate the process is helpful. Getting rid of a bad agent is one of those things.
If your literary agent doesn’t end up fighting as hard for you as you thought they would, lacks communication, doesn’t treat you as an equal partner, then it is better to leave the relationship as soon as possible than allowing it to ruin your attitude towards agents and publishing.
Recognize Real Agents
Literary agents don’t advertise or ask for fees for anything including other services. They list the books they have agented on their website. They are most likely a member of the Association of Author Representatives.
They have phone numbers and physical addresses, so you can contact them face to face or at least hear their voice. And the contracts they oversee make you money without you having to spend money.
Talk to Clients
Before accepting an agent, or if there is a lag in communication, consider contacting the agent’s client list to see what they have to say about their relationship with the agent. This can give you an idea of how the agent truly interacts with their clients and if their way of operating will work well with yours.
Honesty is a Two Way Street
Share what you want your writing and career to look like. What are your goals, hopes, and dreams? When you are honest with yourself and others, it makes it easier for the agent to also determine if you two are a good fit.
Change
Accept that you may not always have the same agent. As careers change trajectory, you may need someone with different skills or tastes. Sometimes you may have more than one agent if you choose to write something that is outside of your current agent’s wheelhouse.
If you continue also writing what your agent loves they may keep you but suggest a different agent who has a focus in your new genre. If you decide that one type of writing sells better or fulfills your writing needs better, you may need to say goodbye and find a new agent.
I recently had someone refer me to their old agent who used to do children’s but the agent decided to focus more on dark, horror, and adult. Knowing that I also have a few ideas for children’s books, and she has experience in that area, means we might be a good fit.
Across the World
Consider agencies outside of your native country. There are imprints from major publishing houses worldwide and your books may appeal to an audience in a different country than where you live. So, having an agent that understands that market and the publishing industry in those countries may be better for your career.
No Agent
If you get tired of querying, don’t despair, self publishing could be the way to go for you or for that specific work. The market changes and what people want fluctuates over time, so querying for years is not unheard of.
For me, I knew after two years of revising, polishing and querying that my book was likely too niche to ever see a publisher’s desk, so I chose to self-publish. However, I have another manuscript that I plan on querying as soon as it is revised.
If your book does well, it could catch the attention of an agent and then they would potentially reach out to you. Then you would go through all of the steps suggested here for when you get an agent acceptance.
Also, small presses and niche publishers accept submissions without agents. Just double check the submission requirements. And check to make sure they don’t ask for any money from you. You may also want to hire a lawyer to look over any contracts.
The Road is Long
Finding a literary agent is a long and difficult process. Sometimes you will feel down by all the rejections and sometimes you will feel excited when you receive requests. These feelings are totally normal. Consider joining the Community | Fictionary.
In this space you can ask questions from other writers on the same journey as you and expert editors. There are spaces to share your celebrations or be consoled during setbacks. Kindness is the word.